Weaned piglets: another factor to be considered for the control of Salmonella infection in breeding pig farms

Field studies on Salmonella infection in suckling piglets are scarce due to the intrinsic difficulties of collecting proper samples (i.e. tonsils or mesenteric lymph nodes), and most of them rely on the analysis of rectal swabs that limit their accuracy. We used 495 slaughtered 4-weeks-old male piglets intended for human consumption from 5 Salmonella-seropositive breeding farms to collect gastrointestinal packages and perform a thorough detection of Salmonella on mesenteric lymph nodes and intestinal content. The overall prevalence of both infection and shedding was high (≈ 36%) indicating that piglets played an active role in Salmonella maintenance in the farms. Major serotypes found in piglets included 4,[5],12:i: (35.4%), Rissen (17.1%), Derby (10.9%) and Bovismorbificans (10.3%). In most of the infected animals (72.8%) the same serotype was found in mesenteric lymph nodes and feces. Significant higher ELISA OD% values were found in meat juice samples from non-infected piglets compared to infected ones (median OD% of 12.0 and 17.3, respectively; P = 0.002) suggesting some protective effect of sow’s colostrum. Salmonella was also isolated from feces from weaned sows contemporary of the slaughtered piglets, and 89% of the serotypes identified in sows were also detected in piglets. Pulsed field gel electrophoresis analyses showed that 75% of the piglet isolates that were compared to those of sows were related to them, suggesting the circulation of Salmonella strains between sows and piglets. It appears that improving piglet colostrum intake along with the reduction of the shedding in sows may favor the control of Salmonella infection in breeding farms.


Introduction
Salmonellosis is the second most commonly reported bacterial foodborne infection in humans in the European Union (EU) after campylobacteriosis [1]. Salmonella spp. were the most frequently reported causative agents of food-borne and waterborne outbreaks in 2017, causing 24.4% of the outbreaks, which represented a moderate increase in EU compared to the 2014-2015 period. The consumption of contaminated pig meat and products thereof is considered one of the most important sources of human infection in Salmonella outbreaks in the EU [1]. Thus, Public Health authorities have advised on the need for control of Salmonella infection in swine, and several EU countries have initiated National Control Programs to reduce its prevalence in the pig population [2].
Pig meat production is a complex process that may be divided in several clearly defined periods: lactation (from the piglet birth to weaning at 3-4 weeks of age), nursery (from weaning to around 2.5 months old or 20-25 kg live weight), and the growing and fattening period (from 20 to 25 kg to 90-110 kg live weight). The dynamics of Salmonella infection has been extensively studied during the latter period [3][4][5][6][7][8], as fattening pigs are intended for human consumption and are considered the main source of Salmonella carcass contamination at slaughter [9,10]. During this period there are multiple opportunities to collect samples either on farm (blood and feces) or at slaughter (blood, meat juice, gastrointestinal content, mesenteric lymph nodes, tonsils or the carcasses). Altogether, this allows for a proper monitoring of Salmonella infection dynamics at this stage and therefore the implementation of suitable on-farm interventions. Thus, most control programs have focused on this period of fattening, and different interventions have been implemented with more or less success to reduce the prevalence of infection on the farm [11,12].
In contrast, there is an important lack of information on the epidemiology of Salmonella infection in the previous production phases, i.e. lactation and nursery even though it may influence the dynamics of infection during the growing and fattening period [13]. During nursery, for example, piglets are highly vulnerable to enteric pathogens, such as Salmonella spp. [14,15]. Bacterial colonization by these pathogens is favored by the intestinal dysbiosis commonly observed in weaned piglets after diet change (from milk-based feed to gross feed) and the stress associated with new environments and the comingling of pigs [16,17]. However, Salmonella infection and shedding is probably overlooked at this stage, mostly due to the common use of in-feed antimicrobials (i.e. colistin, Zinc oxide) that hinders the detection of pathogenic enteric Gram negative bacteria. In addition, proper field studies assessing the prevalence of Salmonella infection in nursery pigs would be expensive, as they would require the unethical slaughter of a large number of young animals.
With regard to suckling piglets in intensive-reared pig farms, a few published studies suggest that the prevalence of Salmonella shedding is, in general, low (< 10%) [3,[17][18][19][20]. Even when pools of fresh feces were used, the mean prevalence of shedding in these piglets was < 5% [21]. However, results from all these studies are based mostly on the analysis of a small amount of feces, in many occasions collected through rectal swabs. Sensitivity of bacteriology from fecal samples is known to be directly related to the amount of feces used for analysis [22][23][24], and thus these studies may have underestimated the true prevalence of Salmonella shedding. Besides, lack of Salmonella shedding does not necessarily prove absence of infection, as intermittent shedding has been observed in Salmonella-infected pigs [3,[25][26][27]. Since suckling piglets may act as a significant source of Salmonella for subsequent production phases, accurate information on the dynamics of Salmonella infection at the end of the lactation period would be of much interest for implementing preventive interventions at this stage.
Roasted piglet (the so-called "cochinillo asado" in Spanish) is a widespread delicatessen food consumed all over Spain. In 2016, more than 1.8 million weaned piglets were slaughtered for human consumption in specialized commercial abattoirs [28]. Thus, for the present study, we took advantage of the availability of these type of abattoirs to assess in a more accurate way the prevalence of Salmonella infection and shedding in a population of weaned piglets coming from breeding farms where Salmonella was circulating. We also evaluated the serological status of these animals with regard to Salmonella specific antibodies to better understand the role that their presence may have on Salmonella infection at this age. All these results should help to shed more light on the risk factors for transmission of this infection within infected breeding farms and design better methods for its control.

Farm selection and collection of samples
Five (A, B, C, D and E) multiplier/supplier Salmonellaseropositive breeding farms from the Northeast part of Spain (one of the largest pig-production areas in Europe) and that showed their willingness to collaborate were included. Farm size ranged from 700 to a maximum of 940 sows. Sampling was carried out in two periods, between February 2012 and July 2013 (farms A, B and C), and March 2015 and April 2016 (D and E). In these breeding farms, female weaned piglets were reared as re-stocking gilts for pig production farms, while male weaned piglets were sent to the abattoir for meat. The males were slaughtered when they reached ≥ 7 kg live weight, which usually occurred at weaning (≈ 4 weeks old -4 wo-). Thus, all the samples analyzed in this study belonged to male piglets of this age.
Piglet samplings were carried out along the year in one abattoir and they depended upon both piglet availability from the five selected farms and abattoir staff readiness for collaboration. The whole piglet intestinal packages were collected directly from the slaughter line every time that a sampling was scheduled. Samples were then submitted to the laboratory for immediate processing. From each package the maximum possible amount of mesenteric lymph nodes (MLN) and as much intestinal content (IC) as possible (from the cecum to the rectum) were collected for bacteriological analysis. A piece of the diaphragm muscle was also collected for serological analysis.
To determine the most prevalent serotypes circulating in the farms, every 3-4 months during the period of piglet sampling, farm staff collected fecal samples directly from the rectum of 10-12 recently weaned sows. These sows were not directly related (i.e. dams) to the studied piglets, but were present in the farm at the same time that piglets were sent to slaughter.
In addition, serum samples from ≈ 120 sows (minimum 116, maximum 158) in each farm were available. They had been routinely collected every 3-4 months during the period of piglet sampling and within the frame of the official eradication campaign for Aujeszky's disease. These sows were not necessarily related to the piglets analyzed either, but they were used to assess the Salmonella serological status in the 5 farms.

Bacteriology
Bacteriology on both IC and MLN samples was performed according to the EN ISO 6579:2002/A1:2007 [29]. Fresh MLN samples were first defatted, weighed, and externally decontaminated by dipping into absolute alcohol and further flaming. Afterwards, samples were homogenized in buffered peptone water -BPW-(Panreac Quıímica SAU, Castellar del Vallés, Spain) in 1:10 dilution and incubated for 18 ± 2 h at 37 ± 1 °C. Thereafter, 3 drops (33 µL each) of incubated BPW were inoculated into a modified semisolid Rappaport-Vassiliadis (MSRV, Oxoid Ltd., Hants, UK) medium, and plates were incubated for 24 ± 3 h at 41.5 ± 1 °C (negative samples were reincubated for an additional 24 h). One microliter of the presumptive Salmonella growth (detected by the halo generated in MSRV after 24 or 48 h) was transferred to two selective media (xylosine lysine deoxycholate [XLD] and brilliant green [BG] agars (Panreac Quıímica SAU). Suspected colonies were confirmed biochemically (triple sugar iron [TSI] agar, urea agar, l-lysine decarboxylation medium, and indole reaction (Panreac Quıímica SAU). One colony of Salmonella spp. per plate from each Salmonella-positive MLN and IC sample was further serotyped at the National Reference Laboratory for Animal Salmonellosis -NRLAS-(Madrid, Spain) following the White-Kauffmann-Le Minor scheme [30].

Pulsed-field gel electrophoresis analysis
To assess the genetic relationship between Salmonella infection (i.e. MLN+) and Salmonella shedding (IC+) for a given piglet, and between Salmonella infection in piglets and Salmonella shedding in sows, pulsed-field gel electrophoresis (PFGE) analysis was performed on Salmonella isolates according to the Pulse-Net protocol [31] as described in detail by [32]. Due to budget restrictions, not all Salmonella isolates were analyzed by PFGE. Only isolates meeting the following criteria were considered for analysis: 1. For the assessment of the relationship of Salmonella infection and shedding in piglets: when the same Salmonella serotype was isolated from MLN and IC samples from the same piglet, then these two isolates were analyzed by PFGE analysis. If this occurred in several piglets from the same farm and within the same batch, a maximum of two piglets per batch were analyzed.

For the assessment of the relationship between Salmonella infection in piglets and
Salmonella shedding in weaned sows: when the same Salmonella serotype was isolated from a piglet's MLN sample and from a fecal sample from any of the sows analyzed from the same farm. A maximum of two piglet isolates and two sow isolates per batch were analyzed.
PFGE pattern analysis was performed with the BIO-NUMERICS software (version 6; Applied Maths, Sint-Martens-Latem, Belgium) using Dice coefficient and unweighted pair group method with arithmetic averages (UPGMA dendrogram type) with a position tolerance of 1.5% and optimization of 2.0%.

Serology
Diaphragm muscle samples were frozen and thawed to obtain meat juice (MJ). Sow serum samples and piglet MJ were kept at −20 °C until their use. To detect specific antibodies (IgG) against Salmonella spp. in both type of samples, the Herdcheck Swine Salmonella ELISA test (IDEXX Laboratories, Westbrook, ME, USA) was used following manufacturer's instructions. This test targets the main swine Salmonella serogroups (B, C1 and D). For piglets, results were presented as optical density percentage (OD%) values. In case sows, a cutoff-value of OD% ≥ 40 was considered to classify a sow as seropositive. This threshold was selected given the low specificity of the ELISA test used [33,34].

Statistical analyses
Piglet prevalence of infection and shedding and their corresponding 95% confidence intervals (95% CI) were estimated. The weight of MLN and IC samples was compared between the corresponding Salmonella-positive

Salmonella isolation, serotyping and serology in piglets
A total of 495 MLN and 495 IC samples were analysed from the corresponding 495 weaned piglets (a mean A median of 7.6 g (95% CI 7.4-7.9) of MLN and of 27 g (95% CI 26.5-27.6) of IC was collected. No significant differences in weights between IC-positive and ICnegative samples were observed (median of 26.8 g and 27.1 g, respectively; P = 0.60). However, the weight for MLN-positive samples was significantly higher than that for MLN-negative samples (median of 8.2 g and 7.3 g, respectively; P < 0.001).
All  Table 2.
Salmonella was not detected in 267 (53.9%) of the sampled piglets, while positive results in both MLN and IC samples were obtained for 125 (25.2%) of them. Of these, 91 (72.8%) showed the same serotype in both samples ( Table 2). A significant association between the isolation of Salmonella in MLN and IC samples was observed: a MLN-positive piglet had around 10 times higher odds of shedding Salmonella than a MLN-negative piglet (OR = 10.27; CI 6.31-16.86; P < 0.001) once the season and farm effects were accounted for (Table 3).

Salmonella isolation, serotyping and serology in sows
A total of 214 fecal samples from weaned sows were collected. The overall prevalence of Salmonella shedding among those was 21.9% (95% IC 16.9-27.9), but it varied significantly between farms, ranging from 2.1 to 40% ( Table 4). The serotypes found in sows differed among farms ( Table 2). The most frequent serotype was Anatum (31.9%) which was present in 3 farms (C, D and E), followed by Kapemba (25.5%; farms A and E), and Brandenburg (17%; farm B). In general, the serotypes most commonly detected in sows were also detected in piglets from the same farm (Table 2).

Table 3 Association between Salmonella infection and Salmonella shedding in weaned piglets by mixed logistic regression analysis
Farm used as grouping factor. IC: intestinal content, MLN: mesenteric lymph nodes, OR: odds ratio.  Six hundred and eighty-six sow serum samples were available from the official eradication campaign for Aujeszky's disease. The overall seroprevalence was 72% (95% CI 68.5-75.2). Seroprevalence varied among farms, but it was always higher than 50% in all of them (Table 4).

PFGE
One hundred and nine Salmonella isolates from piglets met any of the criteria described above for performing PFGE analysis. Twenty-two of them were not included because they belonged to serotypes that could not be typed by this technique (i.e. Panama, Ohio and Kapemba). Thus, 87 (24.6%) piglet isolates ( Figure 1). In 97.5% (39) of the piglets, a PFGE homology ≥ 90% was found between Salmonella isolates from MLN and IC samples. In 22 (56.4%) of them a perfect match (100% homology) was observed.
In piglets from 4 farms (A, B, C and E) the genetic relationship between piglet infection and sow shedding could be assessed (the same serotype found in sow samples was found in at least one of the piglets from the same farm- Table 2). Nineteen Salmonella isolates from sows and 20 isolates from piglets were compared by PFGE. The sow isolates were grouped into 7 different PFGE patterns (> 90% genetic homology), and in 5 of them isolates from piglets were included (patterns I, III, IV, V, and IX- Figure 2). These 5 clusters comprised 75% of the piglet isolates analyzed.
Results from dendrograms also allowed identifying longterm patterns of infection (Figures 1, 2). Major piglets' serotypes showing ≥ 90% PFGE homology were detected in several occasions within the same farm and sometimes with more than 200 days of difference (i.e. in farm A: Rissen; in B: Brandenburg; in C: Derby and Rissen; and in D: Bovismorbificans, Derby and 4, [5],12:i:-). Likewise, homologous Salmonella strains coming from piglets and sows were isolated more than 200 days apart in farm A (4, [5],12:i:-), C (Derby and Anatum), and E (Anatum). In addition, in farms A and B homologous Salmonella strains from sows were isolated more than 300 days apart (4, [5],12:i:-and Brandenburg, respectively).

Discussion
To the authors' knowledge, this is the first field study aiming at assessing the dynamics of Salmonella infection in slaughtered weaned piglets. These piglets were slaughtered for human consumption and were therefore considered clinically healthy and had not received any recent antibiotic treatment. These circumstances may have favored the detection of subclinically Salmonella-infected piglets. At slaughter, whole intestinal packages were collected and a thorough bacteriological study was carried out in order to detect Salmonella from both MLN and IC samples for a better assessment of the true prevalence of Salmonella infection and shedding at weaning, a pig production time scarcely studied [13]. Piglets belonged to farms where the mean within-herd sow seroprevalence remained high (≥ 50%) throughout the study, suggesting an active circulation of Salmonella while piglets were being weaned.
The overall proportion of Salmonella shedders in this population of weaned piglets was unexpectedly high (35.4%), although variable among farms (Table 1). It differed from previous studies on breeding herds that presented levels of sow seroprevalence or prevalence of shedding similar to this one, but that showed a much lower proportion of shedding piglets at this age, i.e. a range of prevalence from 0 to 9% [3,[17][18][19]. Considering the amount of intestinal content analyzed (an average > 25 g per piglet), the sensitivity of bacteriology in this study may have been maximized by the use of a larger amount of IC [22][23][24]. This may help to explain, at least in part, the overall higher prevalence of shedding observed when compared to these previous studies, which may have likely underestimated the true level of Salmonella shedding due to the sampling method used (mostly rectal swabs) in those suckling piglets. Other potential factor influencing these results may be related to the fact these animals were slaughtered and shedding was surely exacerbated by the stress associated with the transport and lairage [9,26], making Salmonella detection more likely.
No previous surveys on prevalence of Salmonella infection were available at weaning. The overall prevalence in MLN was also strikingly high (36%) and virtually identical to that of shedding (Table 1). As many MLN as possible were collected from each piglet, amounting to an average of 8.1 g of MLN per animal. Given the size of MLNs at this age, this represents a substantial number of MLN that covered a large intestinal area (from the small to the large intestine), thus increasing the likelihood of detecting infected animals. This prevalence of infection may have been higher in case tonsils would have been analyzed, as Salmonella seems to persist long periods in tonsils [26], however this type of sample was not available from the abattoir.
Within each farm, the prevalence of Salmonella shedding and infection also seemed to match (Table 1), suggesting a likely relationship between infection and shedding in these piglets. In fact, the odds of shedding Salmonella at weaning was 10 times higher (OR = 10.27; Table 3) for MLN-positive piglets than  PFGE   100  90  80  70   Pattern   I   I   II   II   II   II   III   III   III   III   III   III   III   III   III   III   III   III   III   III   III   III   III   III   IV   IV   IV   IV   IV   IV   IV   This result was somewhat expected since up to 26% of the MLN-negative fattening pigs sent to slaughter may shed Salmonella [8], and shedding would be likely associated with recent infections from contaminated environments during transport and/or lairage. Experimental infections with Salmonella have shown that pigs shed Salmonella quickly after primary infection during approximately two weeks, after which they become intermittent shedders [3,4,[25][26][27]. Given the age of these piglets (4 wo), it seems reasonable that most of these shedding piglets had been infected for first time during lactation. In 97.5% (39/40) of the piglets in which isolates of the same serotype were recovered from MLN and IC, a high genetic homology (≥ 90%) between them was found, and in 55% of them (22/40) a 100% match was detected (Figure 1). These results confirmed these weaned piglets acted as carriers of infection. The fact that they did not show clinical signs of disease emphasizes their potential role in the maintenance of Salmonella infection within these breeding farms. Thus, the presence of Salmonella in weaned pigs should be considered a potential risk factor for infection for pigs raised for slaughter. Strategies to prevent Salmonella infection during lactation and its further transmission to nursery will be required.
The monophasic variant of S. Typhimurium (4, [5],12:i:-) was the most common serotype in piglets (31.4%), followed by Rissen (15.6%), Bovismorbificans (15.3%) and Derby (11.3%). This distribution did not match that of sows, in which Anatum (31.9%) and Kapemba (25.5%) were the most frequently found serotypes, followed by 4, [5],12:i:-and Bovismorbificans (8.5% both). This discrepancy may be related to the fact that only one colony from each positive sample was serotyped, but animals could have been infected by different Salmonella serotypes at the same time [35]. In addition, it might be the result of differences in susceptibility to different Salmonella serotypes between young and adult pigs [27,[36][37][38].
The ELISA test used for serology on meat juice samples from piglets can detect specific immunoglobulins (IgG) against the main Salmonella serotypes found in pigs. Serological results showed significantly lower OD% values in Salmonella-infected compared to non-infected piglets (median OD% of 12.0 and 17.3, respectively; P = 0.002). Seropositivity in all weaned pigs was anticipated after the suckling of sow's colostrum [39]. Maternally derived IgGs were expected to decrease gradually after birth, but then they would increase at 7 weeks of age due to the novo synthesis of immunoglobulins [40]. Thus, in these 4-wo piglets, the IgGs detected by the ELISA were most likely derived from sow's colostrum [41]. The fact that OD% values were higher in non-infected piglets suggests some protective effect of the colostrum against Salmonella infection at this early age. Indeed, there are evidences from field studies showing that colostrum may be a critical factor to prevent Salmonella infection in piglets [42], and some experimental studies have shown that suckling pigs with higher antibody titres improved their resistance when challenged with Salmonella [43,44]. Ensuring proper colostrum intake within the first hours of life should be a basic strategy to prevent Salmonella infection during lactation. Increasing the quality of colostrum (i.e. the amount of immunoglobulins) through vaccination of pregnant sows before farrowing should be considered another potential strategy to protect suckling piglets from infection [43,[45][46][47] and even Salmonella shedding in older pigs [48,49].
Due to the stress associated with weaning, the postweaning period seems to present higher risk for Salmonella shedding in sows [21,50]. For this reason, recently weaned sows were sampled to determine the most prevalent on-farm circulating serotypes. Both the prevalence of shedding in weaned sows and the serotypes found were variable between farms (Tables 2 and 4). Overall prevalence of Salmonella shedding was higher (21.9%) than that reported in other studies with levels of seroprevalence similar to those found here [4,17,21,50,51]. This difference may be attributed to methodological differences between studies, such as including sows of different parities, animal management and immune status.
In agreement with previous studies, the distribution of Salmonella serotypes in these sows differed from those commonly isolated from finishing pigs [17,[52][53][54]. We also found some different serotypes within the farms between sows and piglets. However, 89% of the serotypes detected in the sows were also found in piglets from the corresponding farm. In addition, despite the low number of isolates from sows (19) and piglets (20) that were compared by PFGE, 75% of the piglet isolates were grouped within a PFGE pattern that included at least one Salmonella isolate coming from sows. Altogether this suggests that, in these farms, Salmonella infection can be maintained between sows and piglets. The fact that some Salmonella clones were detected in the farms over long periods (> 200 days) supports this hypothesis. Avoiding Salmonella shedding in sows seems to be important to prevent farm environmental contamination [21] and the subsequent infection of suckling piglets, which would end up shedding this pathogen later. The use of feeding strategies of proven efficacy in reducing Salmonella shedding on slaughter pigs such as fermented feed, some type of organic acids or some prebiotics [55][56][57][58] may help to control the infection in sows as well.
In conclusion, prevalence of Salmonella infection in weaned piglets from Salmonella-positive breeding herds may be much higher than previously reported. This study shows that suckling piglets can become subclinically infected and act as active carriers of Salmonella. There was a close relationship between Salmonella infection in piglets and sows as the same serotypes and strains were found in both populations. Colostrum intake may be a key factor to reduce the likelihood of piglet infection during lactation, but other on-farm strategies to reduce Salmonella shedding in sows are of utmost importance as well.